More News Clips on St. Joe's "Great NOrthwest":St. Joe will go to any lengths to get what it wantsI have already submitted comments on the St Joe Company but there are so many issues with this company that are common knowledge in Gulf County as these people have been doing business here for over 60 years and so are pretty well known in the area. Its hard to make people outside the area understand the
lengths SJ co. will go to get what they want. ...MB, Wewahitchka, 1/24/03 It’s Unanimous, SummerCamp Marches OnwardDespite a public hearing scheduled for the daylight hours, the Franklin County Courthouse Annex building was packed with citizens, various group representatives, and media. By my count, there was 160 folks in the room at the start of the meeting, and up to 200 by the end. It was standing room only. Again, the citizens came to a public hearing to witness the expected approval of the County’s largest development to date. Many had come to speak, many had come to listen, all were full of nervous anxiety as if they already knew the outcome. In a way, they did. From the opening of the hearing led by compassionate Commissioner Cheryl Sanders, it was apparent that the County was behind St. Joe and the rest of the endorsers of SummerCamp. After the initial pitch by St. Joe representative, Billy Buzzett, the civic and environmental groups lined up to give St. Joe their apprehensive blessing. Buzzett, a Franklin County native, discussed the concessions that the developmental plans went through to get to the present proposal, including not moving highway 98 around the gated community’s boundaries, not putting in a marina or boat ramp, and only putting 19 houses in the hurricane flood zone. Also, SummerCamp will have an advanced wastewater treatment facility with a sprayfield 1.5 miles away from the coast and has included provisions to protect stormwater runoff from entering the bay. Buzzett mentioned working diligently with the various groups and State to finalize the plans. In all, there will be 499 houses on 784 acres, much of which will be undeveloped allowing for a clustering of houses in the compatible land. According to information from a local environmental group, the 67% of the land will be left for conservation, leaving one third of the land to be intensively developed. There will be 35,000 gross square feet of commercial space, recreation areas, a fifty room hotel, and other miscellaneous buildings. Instead of individual residential finger docks, there will be one community dock which will have ten slips for boats, and the six foot wide dock will encroach the bay 150 feet past the mean high tide mark. Also, in the plans are ten observation piers that will extend into the bay 200 feet. Although there were several groups supporting St. Joe’s efforts, many in the crowd were either apprehensive or opposed to the proposal. Many citizens asked the County to update the Comp Plan as initially promised before SummerCamp went back to DCA. There were several in the crowd, not being represented by any civic or environmental group, who outright opposed SummerCamp in fear of environmental damage to the Aquatic Preserve and their culture. Two groups, the Panhandle Citizens Coalition (PCC) and the Big Bend Sierra Club, had reservations about the size and location of the project. The overall tallies: 7 speaking in favor (six groups), 13 speaking against (two groups), and 2 neutral citizens. The dissenters claimed that some of their concerns have not been thoroughly addressed in the present proposal. A volunteer from the Red Cross stated development should be directed away from the coast and the hurricane flood zone. The PCC representative had trepidation about the 10% increase in population this would create for Franklin County, and that many of St. Joe’s concessions have not been put in writing. A representative of the Big Bend Sierra Club asked for full protection of Apalachicola Bay and stated that the size and capacity of this development on the coastal fringes is incompatible for the long-term health of the Aquatic Preserve. Several citizens from Wakulla County asked the Commissioners to not make the mistakes of South Florida, to take care of the drinking water, and to be cognizant of the traffic this will present for Crawfordville. A local environmental consultant claimed the proposal does not comply with the previous submittal and that documents used for both submittals are in error. Another local citizen thought limiting the use of lawn and household chemicals would not be feasible and asked to keep land use as agriculture to serve as a buffer. One gentleman drew a series of laughter when he compared “SummerCastle” to an alien spaceship landing and claimed a gated community is inclusive rather than exclusive. A Wakullan claimed St. Joe had much bigger plans than previously revealed: stating plans for a turnpike, a Disney-type amusement park, a transformation of job base for Tallahassee and Panama City. A resident of East Point questioned if the voice of the people was being truly represented and changes in the plan were merely window dressings. Several in the crowd questioned alleged special treatment towards St. Joe versus other developers. Amending the Comp Plan before it is revised and updated would potentially allow other smaller developers to get approval of their amendments. Now that the approval is final with all Commissioners voting in favor, the SummerCamp Comp Plan amendment will be sent to DCA for review a second time. Alan Pierce, mayor of Apalachicola and Franklin County Planning and Zoning Director, reiterated the developer would still have to come back for site plan approval and asked for continued public participation. Much of this participation will come in the “visioning” process, which is being led by FSU’s Urban and Regional Planning Department for a cost of $100,000. So far, the St. Joe Company has committed to half of that expense and several of the supporting groups have committed to a few thousand dollars. Anyone wanting a say in how Franklin County, in particular St. James Island, is to be developed in the future may want to consider contributing to the visioning funds. There still are many loose ends remaining, and many of the groups stated their commitment to making sure the St. Joe Company follow through with all of their concessions. St. Joe is under a lot of pressure to develop SummerCamp to the restrictions imposed, and citizens and groups need to be vigilant. St. Joe has spent years getting state and local laws adjusted to meet their needs, and time will only tell what’s lined up next. Text from a speech by a Franklin County resident at the Commission meeting 1/21/03:I am here today not to talk about the specifics of
the St. Joe requests but rather about a broader and general concern,
about the intangibles of this project. I shall call it a "sense
of community." SummerCamp OK'd by Franklin County CommissionTo no one's surprise, St. Joe's revised SummerCamp
amendment to the comp plan in Franklin Co. passed unanimously. Bruce
Ritchie will no doubt have a detailed piece on the Wed. Democrat. JEB's concern not for the people of the Panhandle, but for his St. Joe business partners
On November 8, 1999 Governor Bush issued Executive order number
99-275 designating eight counties in North West Florida
"rural Areas of critical Economic Concern. This opened the
floodgates for millions of dollars to be given to these counties
for roads, sewer and water, parks, and boat ramps. St Joe co owns
large amounts of land in these counties and money received by
these counties so far have been a benefit to the St. Joe company
in selling their property. I don't believe that Jeb Bush was
concerned about the people of the panhandle as much as he was
looking out for the St Joe Co. who he was once in business with.
The major developments that the St Joe Co. have underway and are
being reviewed by the Resource Agencies have one important element
in common. The Consulting firm that represents the St Joe Co. also
represents Florida Department of Transportation, Army Corps
of Engineers, Department of Environmental Protection,
Florida State Clearinghouse, Opportunity Florida and the Panama
City Airport Authority. There are possibly other agencies who are
represented by PBS&J that I am not aware of but as you
can see, the St Joe Co. has their back side pretty well covered.
... Marilyn Blackwell, Wewahitchka, 9/9/02
Soon the whole state will be on a leash. Florida is rapidly becoming one big, green, chemically fed golf course with space reserved for McMansions, fast food alleys and eight-laned expressways so you never have to get stuck behind some Cracker's old raggedy truck on your way to the beach. From St. Petersburg to Cross City will be a brown-aired conurbation, with subdivisions named after the trees cleared, the lake polluted or the animals driven out in order to build it there. From Tallahassee to Pensacola, the forests will be cut down and the beaches cut off for the benefit of people who can afford to live in pastel fabrications called WindMark, WaterColor and SummerCamp. Old Florida is falling to the developers ....posted by Galloway, 8/18/02 "Florida's Great Northwest: more
than a brand"
|
Like the ballplayer getting booed by opposing fans, just getting noticed is an important sign of success - at least that's the way those of us at "Florida's Great Northwest" regard the recent attention being directed our way.
From down south in Miami to The New York Times, Florida's Great Northwest is causing a stir. That's the first step in telling your story and it is a sign of significant progress.
What we've embarked on at Florida's Great Northwest is an exercise in branding - to spread the word about the comfortable, but energetic lifestyle and the economic opportunities in the 16 counties that make up the region. The long-term goal is to expand and diversify the regional economy so that all the people in every town and hamlet enjoy prosperity.
Whether selling a community or selling a product, you can't just sit back and wait for the customers to walk in. You need to market and promote - not with slickness, but with real facts that tell a true story. As part of that effort, we've created a new place name for a great place - a memorable "brand" that rolls all the attributes into one and sticks in the mind.
Cape Cod, Hilton Head, Vail, Silicon Valley, Research Triangle Park; most who hear those names know immediately the ambience and the activity they represent. Similar, instant recognition, is what we seek for Florida's Great Northwest.
Over the years, the region has had other names, but none of these familiar old handles - "Emerald Coast," "Redneck Riviera," or simply the Panhandle convey all the region has to offer. "Coast" and "Riviera" focus largely on the beachfront - a beautiful, but small part of what the region is about. "Panhandle" conveys only a quirk of geography - but tells nothing about the people or the place.
From the capital of Tallahassee on the east to Pensacola on the west, and north to Alabama and Georgia, Florida's Great Northwest is 13,000 square miles of opportunity.
So what makes it so great?
Water, sunshine, beaches, for sure. But the region is much more than coastal fun and tourism. The coastal area extends but 10 miles inland in a region that stretches up to 100 miles from north to south.
Florida's Great Northwest is also fiber optics; an established aerospace industry that draws on the talent pool from Florida's numerous military bases; a highly skilled and educated workforce backed by such centers of intellectual power as the University of Florida's Graduate Engineering Research Center, Florida State University's Center for Advanced Power Systems, the Gulf Coast Alliance for Technology Transfer, the Institute for Human and Machine Cognition, and the Technology Coast Manufacturing & Engineering Network.
It's also infrastructure that connects businesses easily to the rest of the world - including four commercial airports, 14 public airports strategically spaced across the region, three deepwater ports, and the state's longest east-west connector in Interstated 10. Whether you need to get goods to market or people to a key location, you can get there from Florida's Great Northwest.
Most importantly, "Florida's Great Northwest" is more than a brand. It's also the story of a region pulling together for a common goal. Instead of competition among neighboring communities, civic and business leaders across the region are working together to make this part of Florida a place where businesses and people will demand to be. In health care, education, infrastructure and every area important to quality living, Florida's Great Northwest is about teamwork to achieve greatness.
Some may poke fun, but the people in these 16 counties will laugh last. Above all else, Florida's Great Northwest is about the future. It's about unlocking the natural assets of the region and tapping the energy of its people. It's about taking a great but underappreciated part of Florida and making it a place that conjures magical images whenever you say the name.
__________________________________
"FGNW.org" sounds like a grass roots organization of sorts, but it's really just St. Joe masquerading as the people's favorite. FGNW.org (re the email address above) is registered by Florida's Great Northwest Inc. at 415 Beckrich Rd, suite 350, Panama City Beach, FL 32407 -- one of the addresses of the St Joe Land Co. FGNW.org was registered on 8/29/01, almost a year ago, with a contact address at the St Joe Company.
The following piece is from the Great Northwest portion of the St. Joe Land website:
"Northwest Florida has long been known for its extraordinary white-sand beaches, friendly communities and unmatched quality of life.
Today, it's a region on the move, with public and private sector leaders joining together to push for regional infrastructure improvements while aggressively pursuing world-class economic development opportunities that mesh with existing regional assets.
JOE is an active and vital part of efforts to energize Northwest Florida. In fact, by working in concert with Gulf Power Company, the Northwest Florida Electric Cooperative, and a variety of other stakeholders from both the private and public sectors, St. Joe has helped to establish the region's first-ever not-for-profit economic development partnership, Florida's Great Northwest, Inc.
Florida's Great Northwest, Inc. is committed to building awareness of this 16 county region among site selection consultants and key decision-makers around the world. As this effort continues to build momentum, we fully expect Northwest Florida to become one of the next great places."
If you want to get some perspective on what St Joe has in mind for the folks in the Panhandle go to their Florida's Great Northwest, Inc. website. It's a humbling experience...
Charter schools are supposed to innovate education. St. Joe Co. wants to use charter schools to innovate real-estate marketing. In yet another example of a corporation using insider government contacts to make a buck, St. Joe Co. -- still better known as St. Joe Paper -- wants to build charter schools to serve developments the company plans to build on vast holdings in the Panhandle.
St. Joe, the largest private landowner in the state, long has been a force in Florida politics. The company and subsidiaries such as Arvida have contributed tens of thousands to political candidates and hosted fund-raisers for Gov. Bush and incoming Senate President Jim King, R-Jacksonville. The connections also are personal. St. Joe bought part ownership of Gov. Bush's former company, Codina Group. Though Gov. Bush left the company before the sale, he remains friends with Armando Codina. A St. Joe attorney co-chaired George W. Bush's presidential campaign in the Panhandle.
The charter-school scheme, which The Post outlined, attempted to lean on that political influence. St. Joe -- relying on the connection between executive Billy Buzzett and law-school classmate Robin Safely, now the Florida Department of Education's chief of staff -- successfully lobbied to put a charter-school center at Florida State University near St. Joe's Panhandle operations center in Tallahassee rather than in Orlando. Richard Kunkel, FSU education dean, and Peter Rummell, now St. Joe chairman, both worked for Disney on the Celebration development. Dr. Kunkel wants to help St. Joe get tax-exempt, low-interest loans to build charter schools.
Though Dr. Kunkel says he wants to require participating charter schools to be diverse, state policy allows charter schools to reflect the surrounding community, which in the case of future upscale St. Joe developments means mostly white. To its credit, the U.S. Department of Education has rejected the plan that would use FSU's status to leverage St. Joe school loans. The department should stick by its ruling when St. Joe inevitably heightens the political pressure.
The larger concern is that St. Joe and other developers still will convert charter schools, which operate with public money, into a captive marketing tool. It's part of the same break in the commitment to public schools that has led Gov. Bush to rig the FCAT into a voucher system and let private companies such as WCI Communities divert millions of tax payments to vouchers for use at private schools.
St. Joe's other marketing brainstorm is to change the region's
name from Panhandle to Florida's Great Northwest. With the company
seeking so many public favors, "Panhandle" remains the
better choice.
....Palm
Beach Post Editorial, Sunday, July 21, 2002
After a week spent vacationing on St. George Island near Apalachicola, it's difficult to return to the reality of work.
There, God painted the sunsets in brilliant oranges and reds. Here, the headlines remind me that the stock market is in the tank and the ethics of corporate leaders are in the toilet.
The waters of Apalachicola Bay are still uncrowded, except for the occasional cluster of wooden boats, their occupants, the same as the generations before them, laboring hard to gather the bay's famous oysters.
Life is lived at a slower pace and the name "The Forgotten
Coast" seems appropriate, although there are harbingers of
change, such as the new signs popping up bearing the message:
"No Trespassing. The Paradise Found Association."
.... from Ron Littlepage's editorial in
FloridaTimes-Union, 7/16/02
A new citizens' group has formed in Bay County--the Bay County Citizens' Coalition. The purpose of the private nonprofit organization is to advocate for county government that is committed to high ethical standards, sound growth management, protection of natural resources, and fostering a comm
unity in which all citizens are empowered to maintain or improve their quality of life."Our goal is to make government more responsive to citizens' needs, and to make Bay County a better place in which to live, work and raise children," said Kathryn Ziewitz, the coalition's spokesperson.
Ziewitz said that the BCCC is coming along at a crucial time. "Never before has growth management been more important. Our county is growing fast. Also, the state recently enacted a law giving local governments even more control over local planning, and reducing state oversight. This makes it vital that we have capable, knowledgeable, and ethical local governments that will responsibly manage this growth."
The idea for an organization such as this is not new. There are models in existence in other cities in Florida. Recently, the Bay Chamber of Commerce's Visioning Report noted the importance of having strong citizen participation in government.
However, unlike most such groups, the BCCC will not stop at just commenting. "We have found that sometimes elected officials pay little heed to citizens' comments, preferring to do something other than what is in the best interest of the citizens," said Ziewitz. "That's why we have also formed a Political Action Committee--to remind the voters at election time."
BCCC has established an associated, but separate, PAC. That group will evaluate and endorse candidates for office in Bay County. It will accomplish this by the means of a "scorecard" that will sum up the performance of each candidate, based upon their qualifications, record and where they stand on the issues. Ziewitz said that this first year the group will focus on the county commission race. "In the future we will expand our efforts to include some of the other elections," she said.
At present the group is made up of citizens who are active in local environmental, growth management, civic and neighborhood associations. The group is inviting not only more individuals, but also entire like-minded organizations, to join the Coalition.
Ziewitz said, "When elected officials see that many hundreds, perhaps even thousands, of citizens are joined into one, very strong voice to make Bay County a better place to live, they will listen and respond."
Why is it that county officials and and the state of Florida have
allowed the selling off of the Gulf coast at Alligator Point to
private individuals without creating public access? I am dismayed
and saddened that the beaches of my youth are no longer open to the
public.
I have to drive to Carrabelle or Mexico Beach to enjoy the Gulf
beaches. Shame on the state of Florida and county officials of
Wakulla and Franklin counties.
...DONNA F, letter
to Tallahassee democrat, 7/14/02
Re: "Northwest Florida won't be so 'great' in St. Joe's clutches" by Carl Hiaasen (syndicated column, May 17).
"Hiaasen would be wise to get on a plane to Tallahassee and visit the SouthWood development. This beautiful development is located on the south side of Tallahassee, which most people thought was the "wrong side" of town.
St. Joe was responsible for bringing a major part of the state of Florida headquarters, Florida State University's development school and a new Catholic high school to the south side of area. It is also building a huge residential community that includes a golf course.
Hiaasen should proceed from Tallahassee west to Panama City to inspect the St. Joe involvement in that area. I am sure he will then understand the necessity for a regional airport for this very fast-growing area and relocating a highway system that is a very important part of major community growth.
St. Joe has a million acres of land, which - under Ed Ball's
stewardship - was used to grow pine trees. I, along with Alto
Adams, tried to get Ball to join with Florida's famed Mackle
Brothers in a major community development projects. Ball felt that
his land was in the wrong part of Florida for community
development. Rummell is proving that Ball was wrong and Hiaasen
will quickly find out for himself when he completes his tour."
ARMER W. WHITE
(letter
to Tallahassee Democrat 5/18/02)
This proposed rape and pillage is reason enough for a new Governor. This scheme clearly falls into
the "Do you have any dreams, because we want those too" category. No more beaches for us.
What do you suppose is going to happen to the Correctional Facilities that are a few miles within these gated multi-millon dollar home communitites?? I guess when they shut them down the Correctional Officers can cut grass of clean pools for a living.
This is a very succient vison of our future if we don't stop them in November.
Regards, Dave Galloway, Chattahoochee, FL, 5/12/02
|
For 60 years the St. Joe Co.'s most visible symbol in Port St. Joe was its smoke-belching paper mill. Now local residents know the company for leasing the city's marina, full of expensive boats belonging mostly to outsiders. Below is one of the markers the old St. Joe Paper Co. put on its more than 1-million acres starting in the 1920s.
Morning breaks over Port St. Joe, where the St. Joe Co.'s old paper mill still dominates the landscape. Opened in 1938, it closed in 1998. Now the focus of a toxic waste investigation, the mill is slated for demolition this spring.
St. Joe executives believe a new Panama City airport, to be built on 4,000 acres of St. Joe timberland near Burnt Mill Creek, would spur development on the 70,000 acres the company owns around the site.
To attract thousands of customers to its new housing developments, St. Joe's marketing campaign emphasizes the Panhandle's small-town charm, epitomized by quirky places like Jim McNeill's Indian Pass Raw Bar, south of Port St. Joe.
Maurice Jay takes a break at St. Joe's WaterColor beachfront development in Walton County. St. Joe boasts its developments create jobs; critics contend those jobs will be as servants to the company's wealthy customers.
President Bush recently declared the new airport St. Joe Co. wants to build in Panama City a "high priority" and earmarked $2- million for planning. Others aren't sure the airport would benefit anyone but St. Joe.
New airport and outlet mall
St. Joe wants the government to build a new airport on 4,000 acres of St. Joe-donated timberland, then St. Joe would develop its 70,000 surrounding acres. In Panama City Beach, the company is turning a parcel of swampy park land into an outlet mall and entertainment complex called Pier Park.
Status: Airport scheduled to open in 2006; regulators still reviwing plans and looking into environmental impact. St. Joe broke ground on Pier Park last month; first phase to be complete next spring.
Highways and byways
St. Joe wants the government to build new highways and move old ones. They want to move 4 miles of U.S. 98 near Port St. Joe to create more waterfront property for its WindMark development. They want a new highway (the Gulf Coast Parkway) to connect U.S. 98 with U.S. 231, and a new expressway between Panama City and the Alabama line. Estimated cost: hundreds of millions.
Status: Moving U.S. 98 has been approved; state has put millions of dollars into planning Gulf Coast Parkway; it selected route for the other expressway, but that project is on hold.
Research or recreation
St. Joe wants to build its SummerCamp development at Turkey Point and use FSU land to put a marina next door to the college's marine research laboratory. The marina would serve SummerCamp as well as SouthWood, a St. Joe development in Tallahassee. Also, St. Joe wants to move U.S. 98 inland to create more waterfront property for SummerCamp.
Status: SummerCamp development and moving U.S. 98 have been approved. The marina is on hold.
EVOLUTION OF A GIANT
1924: Alfred DuPont and Ed Ball begin acquiring thousands of acres for what eventually will become the St. Joe Paper Co. Ball takes charge after DuPont's death in 1935.
1938: St. Joe Paper opens its paper mill in Port St. Joe.
1981: The powerful Ed Ball dies. At first, successors make no changes.
1990: St. Joe stock splits 350-for-1, opening the company up to investors who start pushing for it to get into the development business.
1996: St. Joe sells the paper mill. New owner shuts it down for five months in 1997 and closes it for good in 1998, throwing hundreds out of work.
1997: Disney executive Peter Rummell hired to lead St. Joe into its new life as a development giant, a move symbolized the following year when the company drops "Paper" from its name.
1999: St. Joe sells 89 of its 90 lots in The Retreat in Walton County, its first waterfront development. Average price: $400,000.
soon be an airport.
BUSH SIGNS CONTROVERSIAL ANTI-CITIZEN ENVIRONMENTAL BILL DESPITE MORE THAN 100 GROUPS OPPOSING BILL
THREE STRIKES AGAINST GOVERNOR BUSH AS HE CONTINUES TO DISMANTLE ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTIONS: APRIL 4 SIGNED HB715 BILLBOARDS PROLIFERATION ACT; APRIL 11, HB261 TRANSPORTATION ROADZILLAS TO NOWHERE; AND TODAY HB813 SILENCING THE INDIVIDUALS RIGHT TO PROTECT THEIR QUALITY OF LIFE.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BOB BUTTERWORTH RELEASED A LETTER TO THE GOVERNOR REQUESTING VETO OF HB813.
EVERGLADES FUNDING WAS ASSURED UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE (May 15, 2002) Today Governor Bush sided with the politics of exclusion when he signed HB813, a bill which provides a mechanism to fund the state's portion of Everglades restoration; however, the cost to Florida citizens goes well beyond the monetary amount that Florida politicians had earlier committed, at any rate, to pay for Florida's share of the multi-billion dollar project. The new legislation contains provisions making it even more difficult for people to challenge permitting decisions in court.
Editorial boards around the state have overwhelmingly supported a veto of HB813.
And Attorney General Bob Butterworth issued a letter earlier today to the Governor requesting a veto.
Sierra Club was joined by more than 100 homeowner, religious, and environmental organizations across the state of Florida in opposing this bill because of its clear danger to the public interest. Groups include Republicans for the Environment, Legal Environmental Assistance Foundation, EarthJustice, Save the Manatee Club, Florida Defenders of the Environment, Defenders of Wildlife, Buck Lake Alliance, CONA Tallahassee, American Indian Movement, Tallahassee NAACP and many others.
Dan Hendrickson, Sierra Club Citizen Enforcement Issue Chair in Tallahassee, said, "Citizen standing is non-negotiable. Until the very last day of the legislative session, we had been successful in stalling this toxic amendment to the Everglades funding bill we supported. But Senator King and Governor Bush finally embraced the measure that will harm all Floridians, not just Sierra Club."
"The Everglades funding bill, HB813 that Bush signed into law was a Trojan Horse, representing the loss of citizen standing in the courts," said Nancy Brown, president of the Florida League of Conservation Voters in Tallahassee. In the Greek legend, the walls of Troy were breached by a gift; a large horse concealing its true purpose; a force intended to conquer the people of Troy. "In this case, the Everglades money-horse contains new legislation sought by developers who want to further minimize the ability of citizens to contest permitting decisions. The result of this bill will make government unrepresentative and special interest influence virtually impregnable," said Ms. Brown
Few environmental groups supported the effort by Senator King (R-Jacksonville) to include the standings amendment into the Everglades funding bill, claiming that securing money for the Everglades outweighed any taking of citizen rights of standing. However, Sierra Club and its nearly 100 allies, civic, religious, and conservation groups across the state of Florida, sharply differ with this viewpoint.
Helen Spivey, a Co-Chair of Save the Manatee Club & former legislator said, "The Republican leadership used the threat of stopping money for the Everglades to persuade certain favored environmental groups that they must
support diminished citizen rights. Senator King and his cohorts well understood the severe political risks had they failed to fund the state's share of costs toward Everglades restoration, an obligation it had already committed to and one given the highest order of priority by successive presidents, sessions of Congress, and even federal law."
This leads to the question why certain groups were willing to trade an existing right for a promise the Governor could not fail to keep.
"Citizens will now find it much more difficult to participate in local and state permitting decisions which affect every Florida citizen and their environment," said Spivey, adding, "Anyone who believed that funding for the Everglades depended on accepting this devil's bargain needs a quick reality check."
Despite steady opposition throughout the legislative session by Sierra Club, Legal Environmental Assistance Foundation, Save the Manatee Club & others, and strong editorial board support for a veto throughout the State of Florida, Governor Bush signed into law the toxic Everglades anti-citizen standing bill, supported by Audubon of Florida although it severely weakens other environmental and civic groups like Sierra Club which will not meet new and much more restrictive rules for standing.
Explains Arlene Sweeting, conservation chair for the Sierra Club Florida Chapter, "Sierra Club has chapters in every state in the nation. We are incorporated in California, where our organization was founded, and represent more than 750,000 members across the nation and 29,000 Florida members. By excluding non-Florida corporations from standing, our greatest contribution to the public interest has been stripped away. We strongly object to the concerted actions of Senate president Jim King, Governor Bush, and Audubon of Florida."
"While we are all for land acquisition to save the Everglades, this is a low moment for the environmental community," said Alan Farago, co-chair of the Sierra Club's Everglades committee, "when another organization turns it back to accept a devil's deal trading fundamental rights for what was already a sure thing --State funding for Everglades restoration."
Tom Reese, a Public Interest Environmental Attorney for over 20 years, affirmed that, "The exclusionary tactics of the new law impact far more than Sierra Club's Florida citizens --they affect all Florida citizens. The new law radically changes the relationship of citizens to their government, specifically hindering citizens from forming ad-hoc groups to contest bad permitting decisions by local government."
Strike One: "In signing this bill, Governor Bush betrayed conservative principles he used to justify signing another controversial bill related to billboards", said Marion Hillard, Government/Agency Liaison and past President, Florida Federation of Garden Clubs, Inc. In a letter to Secretary of State Katherine Harris on April 4th, Governor Bush asserted the rights of private property and the need to empower local government in order to counter the weight of state authority. Governor Bush wrote, "Such a failure of the checks and balances of government power would be pernicious. Similarly, we, as a people, do not deserve the further diminishment of our rights ..."
"But apparently the Bush administration will not extend the same care to people as he does for billboards, unless they belong to certain favored organizations. By such acts, "compassionate conservatism" has been swept by Governor Bush into the dustbin of history," said Ms. Hillard.
Strike Two: Keith Schue, Group Chair of the Central Florida Sierra Club, stated that "Strike two was the April 11th signing of HB261, the new law essentially transforms FDOT from an agency whose role was to provide transportation solutions for the people of Florida into an agent of sprawl."
Susie Caplowe, Florida Chapter Sierra Club lobbyist, concluded, "Governor Bush can't paint over the damage that has been done: the radical weakening of citizen rights is now added to other terrible bills that Governor Bush signed into law last month. That's three strikes against the Governor."
SAVE THE MANATEE CLUB is an internationally known organization with over 40,000 members.
SIERRA CLUB, America's oldest conservation organization, was founded in 1892 and has over 750,000 members across the nation, with chapters in every state.
FLORIDA FEDERATION OF GARDEN CLUBS, INC has over 18,000 members and is active in issues relating to the improvement of our quality of life.
FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CONSERVATION VOTERS is a 28 year old, non-partisan political watchdog organization, comprised of a network of leaders from environmental and public interest organizations throughout Florida. # # #
Organizations requesting a VETO of HB813 and that a Clean Everglades bill be sent to the Governor without the Anti-Citizen Standing/participation language found in SB270/HB819.
Organizations requesting a VETO of HB813 and that a Clean Everglades bill be sent to the Governor without the Anti-Citizen Standing/participation language
found in SB270/HB819.
Citizens United for Responsible Growth
Lake Carolyn Estates
Centerville Road Rural Alliance
Martin County Conservation Alliance
Friends of the River, Inc
Greenspace Preservation Association
Glen Springs Preservation Association
Indian River Keeper
Treasure Coast Environmental Defense Fund
Florida Council of Churches
Tallahassee Branch NAACP
Environmental and Land Use Law Center
Evergladesia, Worldwide Wetland Stewardship
Citizens for Alternatives to Pesticides
Sawmill Slough Conservation Club
Betsy Wood Environmental Fellowship Fund
Connecticut Club of Sarasota
Defenders of Wildlife
Alliance to Protect Water Resources, Inc
Lutz Civic Association
Save Our Shoreline, Inc
Congregation L'dor Va-Dor
EverGreen, the Tree Treasurers of Charlotte County
Florida Native Plant Society
St. Augustine Chapter of the Surfriders Foundation
Earthjustice, Inc.
Florida Clean Elections Campaign
Consumer Fraud Watch
Save Our Bays and Canals
Volusia Flagler Environmental Action Committee
Coalition for Family Safety
Florida Watch
Sarasota Seniors Coalition
Midwest Soarring Foundation
American Indian Movement of Florida
Floridians for a Sustainable Population
Florida League of Conservation Voters Education Fund
The Florida Institute for Economic Justice, Inc
Gulf Coast Environmental Defense
Citizens for a Rational Energy Policy
Santa Rosa Sound Coalition
Hollywood North Beach Association
Farmworker Association of Florida
Citizens Against Toxic Exposure
Citizens for a Scenic Florida
Florida Coalition for Peace & Justice
Clean Millennium Movement
ECO-Action
ECO-Store
Earthwise Productions, Inc.
Florida Defenders of the Environment (FDE)
Active Citizens Together Improving Our Neighborhoods (ACTION)
Republicans for Environmental Protection - America (REP)
Mike Sheridan, Businessman & concerned citizen
Tampa Bay Action Group
Clean Water Action
Friends of Perdido Bay
Lake Okeechobee Business Owners and Supporters (LOBOS)
Al & Jan Whittle, Homeowners in Yorkshire sub-division
Save Our Suwannee, Inc
Save The Homosassa River Alliance
Friends of The Fenholloway
Around the Bend Nature Tours
Environmental Confederation of Southwest Florida (ECOSWF) 33,000 members
Manasota88
Sojourner Truth Center
American Littoral Society
ReefKeeper International
Sarasota Citizens Against Pollution, (SCAP)
St. Andrew Bay Resource Management Association, Panama City, FL
Conservation Alliance of St.Lucie County
Friends of the Wekiva River Inc.
Sierra Club Florida Chapter
Friends of the Everglades
Independence Party of Florida
Izaak Walton League, Manatee Sarasota Chapter
Izaak Walton League, Mangrove Chapter
Izaak Walton League, Florida Keys Chapter
Buck Lake Alliance, Inc.
Florida Bi-Partisan Civic Affairs Group
Council of Neighborhood Association (CONA), Tallahassee 58 Neighborhood Associations, approx 12000 homes
Florida Public Interest Research Group, 10,000 members
Florida Consumer Action Network, 40,000 members
Save the Manatee Club, 45,000 members
Legal Environmental Assistance Foundation
Florida League of Conservation Voters
Tom Reese, Public Interest Attorney
Floridians For Environmental Accountability and Reform
Shannon Larson, Concerned Citizen
Jamie & Kathleen Lewis, Concerned citizens
Bobby C. Billie, Spiritual Leader Independent Traditional Seminole Nation of Florida
Sumter Citizens Against Irresponsible Development (SCAD), 135 members
Coalition For Anti-Urban Sprawl Efforts (CAUSE), 100 members
Miami-Dade Green Party
Hernando County Green Party
Tallahassee Green Party
Pasco County Green Party
Broward County Green Party
Citizens for Sanity, 280 members
Martin County Residents for Responsible Growth
Arthur M. Marshall Foundation
Florida Federation of Garden Clubs, Inc., 18,000 members
Florida Clean Water Network
Steve Watrel Professional Association
Citizens for Scenic Jacksonville
Citizens for Tree Preservation
North Riverside Community Development Corporation (CDC)
Resource Analysis and Management
Biodiversity Legal Foundation
5/15/02 Compiled by Susie Caplowe, Sierra Club Florida Chapter
(850)385-6160
Florida League of Conservation Voters
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
PRESS STATEMENT:
FLORIDA CHAPTER SIERRA CLUB
FLORIDA LEAGUE OF CONSERVATION VOTERS
SUSIE CAPLOWE:
(850) 567-2448
ORGANIZATIONS REQUESTING VETO PASSES
100 MARK! AND
ATTORNEY GENERAL BOB BUTTERWORTH
RELEASED A LETTER TO THE GOVERNOR REQUESTING VETO OF HB813.
TALLAHASSEE: The number of grassroots organizations calling for Governor Jeb Bush to veto the poisoned Everglades funding bill and schedule a special session to draft a "clean" funding bill passed the 100 mark today, pulled together by Sierra Club and the Florida League of Conservation Voters. Governor Bush's choice is clear -- he either is with the developers and polluters or he is with the citizens, said the Sierra Club. The Governor's office reports that e-mails, phone calls, and letters against HB 813 with the poisonous provision have been pouring into his office. The Editorial boards around the state have overwhelmingly supported a veto of HB813. And Attorney General Bob Butterworth issued a letter today to the Governor requesting a veto. The anti-citizen amendment restricts the ability of ordinary citizens to band together to fight bad permitting decisions and to challenge proposed projects.
This amendment will undo 30 years of
legal precedents and call into doubt the most elemental of citizen
rights.UNDER THE PROPOSED LEGISLATION, THE IMPACTS TO CHAPTER 120, THE
ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURES ACT, LET ALONE 403.412.(5) THE ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION ACT WOULD BE THAT CHALLENGES MAY ONLY BE FILED BY
ORGANIZATIONS THAT FIT THE FOLLOWING PROFILE:* May only be filed by a
Florida corporation, which cuts out public-interest groups
such as the Sierra Club, LEAF, Earthjustice, Inc and many homeowner and
civic associations. The Sierra is incorporated at its
headquarters in California though we
have 29,000 Floridians dedicated to protecting Florida's communities,
public health and environment. *
Must have 25 members in the county where the project is proposed.* Must
have been incorporated at least one year before the permitting
application is filed with your local or state government agency. Ad hoc
affiliations of concerned citizens, which
promptly band together to protest a bad decision by government, would be
precluded from going through the administrative procedures process.
* Must be formed for the purposes of
the protection of the environment, fish AND wildlife resources, AND
protection of air AND water quality. The
proposal also establishes a new test for associational standing.
Standing to initiate an s. 120.569 and s. 120.57 hearing would exist if
the petitioner is a non-profit Florida corporation; if it has 25 members
within the county where the activity is proposed; if the corporation was
formed for the purpose of the protection of the environment, fish and
wildlife resources, and protection of air and water quality, and if it
was formed at least one year prior to the date the application for the
permit or license was filed. (Department of Environmental Protection,
Final Bill Analysis)
Top